Skip to main content

Marshall Beeber, Messianic Jew is a Closet Dispensationalist.

Marshall Beeber, a Messianic Jew, is actually a closet Dispensationalist. He says he is a historic premillenialist. But he believes that Romans 12 talks about Israel as a government, a nation, being holy. That is not what Romans 12 is about. Romans 12 is about individual Jews becoming Christians, the elect, all the elect Israel, being saved. All the elect Israel is made up of Jewish and Gentile believers.

So Beeber, who says he is not a Dispensationalist, is a sneaky pro Israeli Dispensationalist who chided me for believing that 9/11 and other conspiracies show Israeli involvement.

But clearly, read up about the Lavon Affair, where Israelis attacked US government property in Egypt. Israel admitted to it in 2005, 51 years after it happened. No one died, but that is not the point. It was a false flag attack on the USA.

I am a citizen of the USA. I put the USA first except for a spiritual citizenship in the new Zion, a spiritual Zion of peace, not one that is physical (Israel) of war like Beeber supports. If I were a resident of Israel I would oppose the regime change in the Arab states and the occupation of the Palestinians, which is slavery, just like I do here.

If I were a resident of Israel I would seek a legitimate defense of the homeland, but not a destruction of all other nations around me, which is happening now in the middle east with regime change.

I cannot support militant Zionism. It is evil and murderous. It is a movement that seeks world domination. How can a movement that seeks world domination be Christian? It can't. I urge Jews who seek peace, who live in Israel, to move if they can. If they can't then I pray for peace for them.

Beeber should reassess if he is in the faith. The truth of the matter is that Beeber is not an historical premillenialist, he is a Dispensationalist which leads to a Christian Zionsm, and he is a liar.


  1. Gary Anderson is correct in his estimate that my eschatological leanings are Dispensational. I though do not hold to a pre-tribulation Rapture doctrine but am more Mid to Post Tribulational in my beliefs. I therefore have preferred to refer to my beliefs as "Historical Pre-Millenial", but like Dispensational thought , I firmly hold to a belief that Israel is pre-destined to be reconciled with God upon Messiah's (Jesus Christ) physical return at the end of this age. You can better understand my doctrinal beliefs in my article "Prophetic Promises Given To Israel" at .

    I only have communicated with Gary Anderson a few times. He seems to have a lot of zeal but accuses me of being a liar. His response shows a certain lack of Biblical wisdom and a willingness to smear another believers personal reputation for the sake of winning his argument. He also holds to a conspiracy theory towards Jews, Israel and Zionism that one could only refer to as leaning towards Neo-Nazi myth. After he expressed these conspiracy theories to me I immediately ended our correspondence. I hold no ill will towards Gary, but hopes he uses his blog in the future in a more Biblically loving fashion.

    In Messiah's grace,

    Marshall Beeber
    Messianic Literary Corner director

  2. Recent Anti-Zionist gatherings in Europe have finally convinced many decent individuals that they are only a guise for Anti-Semitic hate speech. Recently a German judge pronounced a German citizen guilty of Anti-Semitic hate crimes for masquerading as Anti-Zionist at public gatherings. See the article at . I believe those that read Gary Anderson's articles should call him out to discover his true motivations. Ask him about his "Conspiracy Theories" regarding Israel, Zionism and Jews!

  3. There are some racists who oppose Israel. But that is wrong. Opposing Israel is not saying that Israel is not a sign to the Jews that God is now calling them. Opposing Israel is saying that this sign is nothing more than a sign, and is a fake Zion with no legitimacy in its actions. It will be judged as a nation. Jews enter eternal life the same way as Gentiles, as individuals. That is the essence of the New Covenant which Dispensationalists deny.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Revelation Timeline

This timeline of the Book of Revelation, written after the destruction of the temple in 70 AD, was originally posted at this static page on this blog entitled Essential Articles/END TIMES:


Here is a brief timeline regarding the Book of Revelation. Clearly, the book of Revelation was written after the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 AD. The real destruction was to follow.

And clearly also, most of the prophets who were killed were killed in Jerusalem. The Great City clearly refers to Jerusalem multiple times. However, the destruction of the beast does not. I am putting this timeline out there. I believe it has merit and makes more sense than other timelines, especially Dispensationalist timelines which are created out of thin air:

1. Rev chapter 18 speaks to the destruction of Jerusalem but was written after the destruction of the Temple in 70 AD. It could speak to the completed destruction after 70 AD, in 135 AD, when Jerusalem was literally ploughed under. In 70 AD, 30,000 He…

Predestined to Hell

The human mind cannot always take in the sobering reality of predestination. We who are predestined are greatful, but sorrowful. We know many we love are not so predestined. It hurts. Paul said he could wish that he would suffer if his kinsmen would be saved.

But it is also that same Apostle Paul who told the truth in Romans chapter 9, that some vessels were created for special use, like fancy kitchenware, and others were created for menial use, to be thrown away.

The truth is, sin is created by those who are not kept from it. The devil and Adam created sin in their acts of defiance, having been permitted to have a will apart from the will of God. They used that will to create sin. It is always that way. Only God is good, and only His Will is sinless.

So then, there are a few predestined to heaven, through God given faith. And there are many, including many who believed in predestination like Calvin and the Protestants, who are predestined to hell. They were created for menial use onl…

My Gedmatch Sephardic and Moroccan Jewish DNA

Here is my Sephardic and Moroccan Jewish connection on Gedmatch, clearly defined:

l data has been read. 20 approximations mode.
Gedmatch.Com HarappaWorld 4-Ancestors OracleThis program is based on 4-Ancestors Oracle Version 0.96 by Alexandr Burnashev.
Questions about results should be sent to him at:
Original concept proposed by Sergey Kozlov.
Many thanks to Alexandr for helping us get this web version developed.

23 April 2013 - Oracle reference population percentages revised.

Admix Results (sorted):


Finished reading population data. 377 populations found.
16 components mode.


Least-squares method.

Using 1 population approximation:
1 french @ 7.677426
2 spaniard @ 10.572488
3 spaniard @ 11.531779
4 italian @ 14.496882
5 utahn-white @ 16.649788
6 hungarian @ 17.595961
7 british @ 17.715258
8 n-european @ 18.111269
9 …